Historic Courthouse supposedly haunted
City landmark or haunted history? Since its construction in 1889, the old courthouse has survived some pretty severe events. In 1912, the courthouse caught fire due to faulty electrical wires. The clock tower was destroyed and three firefighters perished that night. The very next year, Hamilton was hit with torrential rains that caused the Great Miami River to flood so badly it covered most of the city. Approximately 200 lives were lost in the flood, and the historic courthouse was used as a morgue for 10 days following.
Historical Society
Nestled off Second Street in German Village is the Butler County Historical Society. The home was previously owned by Prussian immigrants, John and Wilhelmina Benninghofen, whom resided there for a number of years. After a group of ghost hunters reportedly made contact with her in 2013, it has been said that Wilhelmina is still keeping a watchful eye on her home.
Hamilton Vision Source
It’s a good thing that 712 Dayton Street is now home to Hamilton Vision Source, because some may think they need an eye exam upon walking in. It has been said that Mrs. Schuler, the former First Lady of the home, is still lingering. She has been seen sitting quietly on a bench at the bottom of the stairs, and many have stated they can still feel her energy in the home.
Wayne Park (Rossville Cemetery)
Located on the west side of Hamilton is Wayne Park, previously known as Sutherland Park. But many years even before that, this plot of land had a much graver purpose. This area was one of only two burial grounds for the original pioneers of Hamilton. Established in 1804, the cemetery proved to be an unsuccessful burial location due to deterioration. The graves were relocated to Greenwood Cemetery, and by 1890 the space was established as Sutherland Park.
McKenzie & Snyder – 229 Dayton Lane
Prior to operating as a law firm, 229 Dayton Lane functioned as the W.F. Cahill and Sons Funeral Home for approximately 70 years. Local paranormal investigators staked out the law firm in 2013, and found unexplainable footsteps and shadowy figures. It has also been reported that the phone will ring without reason and the front door will open on its own. Could 229 Dayton Lane still be home to a few guests from the funeral home?
Princeton Road, by Rose Hill Cemetery
It is said that a local student was on her way to prom when the terrible weather caused her to lose control and crash off Princeton Road, by the Rose Hill Cemetery. She did not survive the accident, and it is said that she can still be seen trying to hitchhike her way to prom. Some have reported actually picking her up, only to have a cold chill creep down their neck and their passenger disappear into thin air along the way. For those who opt not to give a ride, they are said to fall victim to a minor accident themselves shortly after.
Basil 1791 (Ryan’s Tavern)
While the building is now operating as one of Hamilton’s hotspots, the same location has housed many different businesses throughout the years. It was a men’s store in 1892, a shoe shining parlour in 1912, and more recently, Ryan’s Tavern. Over the years, there have been reports of a ghostly kitchen assistant and a haunted elevator that will open on its own from time to time.
New London Road
If you’re ever out on New London Road, watch out for joggers! Since the 1970s, it has been said that a wealthy doctor who lived in the area suffered a fatal heart attack while out for a run. Drivers have reported seeing a runner wave as they pass him driving up the hill, but once they reach the top, that same runner is standing there smiling before he disappears.
Miami University Hamilton
Every school has their own legends and stories, and Miami University Hamilton is no exception. Since its establishment in 1968, there have been reports of a woman’s ghost haunting the 4th floor of Mosler Hall. It is said that this woman died when she fell down the elevator shaft. Her screams can still be heard from time to time.
Butler County Treasurer’s Office
Prior to its relocation to the Government Services Center, the Butler County Treasurers Office was housed in the historic courthouse. In the 1860s, a man was killed during a robbery in the office. The robbers then attempted to make it look like a suicide to cover up their crime. It is said that the ghost of that man still haunts the office, and had been known to make the clock chime 21 times.